LGR – Wing Commander – DOS PC Game Review
Articles Blog

LGR – Wing Commander – DOS PC Game Review

September 30, 2019


[typing]
[saxophone jazz music] Wing Commander. Developed and published by Origin
Systems in 1990 for MS-DOS PCs. This is one of those legends of
computer gaming that set the standard for an entire subgenre, that being spaceship
combat simulation. Sure, there were plenty of space games
and combat flight sims prior to this, from Starflight’s cosmic exploration and trading to Microprose’s real-world air combat excursions. But it was Wing Commander and its
particular blend of action-focused gameplay and cinematic presentation that cemented what this type of game would
feel like for years to come. This resulted in an array of
sequels, spinoffs and competitors that culminated in a market
oversaturated with space combat games that were arguably too complex for their own
good, with the genre reaching a plateau by the late
’90s and languishing until the 2010s. In both cases, it was developer Chris Roberts that tossed rocket fuel onto the space game
flame with him manning the helm
on both Wing Commander and its spiritual successor, Star Citizen. Although, let’s be fair, he also directed the 1999 Wing Commander movie with Freddie Prinze, Jr. Hmm… On second thought, maybe THAT’S
what killed space flight games back then. Anyway, Wing Commander
came in a pretty stellar package with cover art precisely evoking the mood
of the game. Sci-fi stuff EXPLODING in front of YOU in
a cockpit. This is the so-called
“Special Promotional Release” here. Although the only thing “special” about it
is… that it was a secondary print run
sold at stores like Costco. There’s also the blue box Deluxe Edition, which is a compilation featuring both of
the “Secret Missions” expansion packs. In either case, though, you get a fantastic
amount of old-school goodies inside, starting with the game itself on
either 5¼-inch or 3½-inch floppy disks. And if you got the wrong kind, you could
just send in this form to swap ’em out. You also got a registration card, an Origin product catalog with the
expected crapload of Ultima games, a couple reference sheets and manual addendums, four generously sized spaceship blueprints
that fold out into sweet freakin’ posters, and a 48-page instruction manual in the form
of an in-universe Claw Marks magazine. Even without the game, these things
are worth the price of admission alone! Ahh, how I miss the ’90s. At least in terms of all the cool crap
you got with PC games and not like… I dunno, bowl cuts. There’s also this amazing piece in my copy, with revolver clip art and the DOS
command for defragging the hard drive. Or, my bad, “Def-Raging.” Yeah, someone was definitely
raging when they printed this out, if the gun is any indication. Speaking of rage… getting Wing Commander to run
correctly can be a bit of an ordeal. You’ll need a moderately
spec’d 386 with expanded memory to access all the animations
and get a decent frame rate, but you can’t go TOO fast
or else the game just flips out. I had to disable the cache on my
66 MHz 486 to get it running well. And even on DOSBox it’s still not perfect, even when using finely tuned CPU cycles. Although around three, three-and-a-half
thousand seems to work pretty well. But it’s worth the hassle to get it sorted because, man, Wing Commander really
stands out among its peers from 1990, starting with this intro. [epic MIDI music and laser sounds] Yeah, Wing Commander does not waste any time letting you know it means business in
the cinematic presentation department. You begin by losing this
arcade game/training sim– a clever way to have you input
your player name and call sign. You then find yourself aboard a
Terran Confederation Strike Carrier, known as the Tiger’s Claw. In a bit of point-and-click adventure-iness, you’re free to talk to the bartender
and any patrons in the room to make some introductions
and catch up on space gossip. Or ignore them and wander around
the ship, admiring the scenery. These 27th-century luxury accommodations
also act as the main menu where you’ll check your stats, exit to DOS, start a scenario, or save and load your game. I especially love the save system where
you click these bunks to place a sleeping pilot and then you wake them up to load a game. It’s the little things, you know? But the big stuff is where the game really
begins, like these animated briefings before each
mission. And while there’s no voice acting in this
version, this intro sequence still absolutely psyches
me up! [intense MIDI music] I’m READY to command some WINGS! And what better way to do that… than with the 1991 Thrustmaster
Flight Control System, which just feels right with a game like this. With your stick firmly gripped, you’re given free reign with what to do next. But there’s a tutorial for the first mission included in the box, if you need guidance. The majority of the 40 missions begin with
you and a wingman departing the Tiger’s Claw, and a set of navigation points to navigate
to, point by point. You can either fly there manually or lock
onto them using the nav computer and use autopilot, which acts a fast-travel mode
and gives you this sweet 3D fly-by. Well, as 3D as it can manage anyway, since the whole game uses 2D
imagery and scaling to simulate depth. Before long, you’ll run into some kind of
resistance, often things like asteroids,
minefields or enemy ships. The main enemy in the game
are known as the Kilrathi, a species of bipedal feline alien warriors that could really use some catnip or
something because they’re pissed. There are a variety of vessels
you’ll come up against, each of which will often fight to the death, regardless of their own equipment or size. Sometimes it’s just you and your partner
you’ll have to keep up with and provide orders to, other times you’ll have weaponless
transport vessels to defend. Either way man, when it’s time to throw down, it gets intense;
especially when you consider its contemporaries. Just compare the experience to something like
Lightspeed, which released the same year… [understated Adlib sound effects] And then comes Wing Commander, with its theatrical
flair and grandiose George Sanger soundtrack that sounds great on the Adlib and MT-32 alike! [intense Adlib music and laser sounds!] [triumphant music!] Granted, these are two very different space games at their core, but the point I’m trying
to make is that Wing Commander was truly ahead of the curve overall. Seeing as this predates the Star Wars X-Wing
and Tie Fighter games by several years I think it’s safe to say that Wing Commander was a landmark in space combat. It might be a bit primitive now
with its weird scaling sprites inelegantly rotating in your face, but that doesn’t stop the
adrenaline rush from kicking in when you’ve locked onto
one of those hairballs and fired a heat-seeking missile up their butt. And it really doubles down on those moments with a control scheme that’s very playable with a simple two-button joystick or mouse. Most of the ship’s controls are
delegated to the keyboard, of course, but… even those are pretty minimal
compared to later space combat sims. There aren’t even any loadouts or upgrades
or anything like that to worry about since the game takes care of that stuff for
you by providing different ships for different
missions. It’s still effective in making you
feel like an amazing space pilot, but the actual combat and space flight stuff is a bit rudimentary when it comes down to
it. In fact, it’s the stuff in between the action that keeps me engaged the most. Once you’ve fulfilled your objectives
and make it back to base, you relay the outcome of
your mission to your superior and then are given a speech by them about how you performed and what to do next. Sometimes you’ll be sent back to your quarters, sometimes you’ll be reassigned. Other times you’ll be given
a promotion or a medal in recognition of your performance. There’s even a set of events that
unfold if you eject and lose your ship, with the missions and
storylines shifting its narrative as the result of each of these actions. In terms of helping you feel like you’re
actually making a mark on this universe, Wing Commander does a lot for a game of this
time. It does its best to make sure
it doesn’t feel like a series of loosely connected skirmishes, but instead you’re a guy
rising through the ranks while making a difference one way or another. Characters are growing, conflicting and dying and not following orders all along the way. And combined with the ever-changing
technology you’re encountering, it does a bang-up job of
keeping the story moving forward. And it’s not always easy, either. In the later missions,
and especially the Secret Missions, death is a pretty constant possibility. For me, it tends to reach a
point of frustration later on, and I quickly tire of replaying
the same mission over and over, just to die at the same point 20 minutes in. A lot of that is due to my
own lack of time these days, but when Wing Commander
was a new and fresh experience that kind of difficulty wall
might have been more forgivable. It was certainly forgivable
enough for Wing Commander to receive a number of ports
and updates over the years, on systems like the Commodore Amiga, Super Nintendo and Sega CD. Then there was Super Wing Commander, a 1994 remake that featured a
substantial audio-visual update of the game for the 3DO and Macintosh systems. Pretty awesome stuff in a way, but I dunno. It’s still kinda weird to me that they
completely changed the characteristics of so many of the ships and characters. Still, Wing Commander in all its various forms is something that’s a lot of fun
to go back to from time to time and cherish its high points and its quirks
alike. It may not be the most advanced
combat space thing of its kind, but it’s a trendsetter that remains
rather timeless, in my opinion. It’s also currently sold digitally
on services like GOG and Origin. So if shooting evil space cats
with lasers sounds like a good time, then why not grab your stick… and dive into Wing Commander
and have some fun! [jazzy MIDI music] And if you enjoyed this
episode of LGR, then awesome! Perhaps you’d like to see some of these others. There’s new videos every Monday and Friday, and if you would like to see them early, you could support the show on Patreon. And as per usual, thank you
very much for watching LGR.

Only registered users can comment.

  1. Air warrior 3 ..…now that's where it was at to this day no other game matches it …. It was on AOL game for a couple of years then it just disappeared 😭 then I found a light independent server but that was quickly shut down…..and that was one of the funnest most realistic games of ever played and it was multiplayer player…… Took 8 hours to download.. but that game was straight-up the best,,,, then one day it was just gone Gone Gone Gone spent years looking for it no luck then MechWarrio3r is pretty good though along with the rest of the mechwarrio3 games..,……

  2. I had it on the Amiga It looked better but its slower, but it runs very good on a FPGA machine. FPGA is the way to play 8 and 16bit games etc
    I do own ZX Spectrum 128 and Amiga A1200.

  3. Memories of when things we consider simplistic now, were awe inspiring. Hobbes rules!

    And Ultima ruled too.

  4. I am really alone with actually liking the wing commander movie???

    I mean… just look at how crappy the doom movie is compared to that or how great the score is.

  5. Wing Commander was a big game changer *only* in the United States. In Europe we had Elite 5 or 6 years earlier, which was the true game changer, and used actual 3d graphics (wireframe initially then polygons).

  6. WC1 and WC2 were my favorite past time as a kid. God…and WC3 too, it was the first video game I remember with live action cut scenes. And an all star cast. And in all three games, losing missions changes the course of the game, in WC3 you could get stuck in a no-win defense of Earth against an invincible Kilrathi dreadnaught. sigh….memories.

  7. I missed SOOOOOOO many days of school because of this game. "Uhhh, dad…I'm sick. cough cough…. guess Ill have to stay home and slaughter Kilrathi!"

  8. Are you spacing yourself when you exit to DOS? O.o; That's what the door calls to mind, especially with the way it looks.

  9. I loved the Sega CD version of this. The voice acting and music made it feel so amazing. It would be years later when I finally got around to the PC version.

  10. I played this in 1993 and I remember blowing through the missions as quickly as possible in order to get to the next story segment.

  11. love the briefings when a mission start.. just like the X-Wing Vs Tie Fighter.. That they do not do anymore either..

  12. The Alien Ant Farm logo looks similar to the one on the side of the fighter at 4:50. Maybe they were fans of this game too.

  13. The hours I used to spend playing this game. And when I got a SoundBlaster card–oh yeah. Offloading the sound to the card got the framerate up on my 386DX/20.

  14. Oh man, I remember installing the game port card in our Packard Bell 486 so I could use a joystick to play F-15 Strike Eagle II. That's probably the first PC game I sunk any significant time into.

  15. I don't remember it being that slow and laggy in combat back in the day on my parents old 486/66 DX2 with a Soundblaster – but man, I played the CRAP out of that game.

  16. I played WC: Prophecy as a kid, and sorta got it working again using some patches, largely fan-made.

  17. Ah…I wish I still had my box from WC1…but I've got all the blueprints and ClawMarks mag still 🙂

  18. Star Trek DOS Games! And early Windows Games! Please review some. Thanks. PS: Indians Jones: Last Cruisade and The Fate of Atlantis!

  19. When I worked at Origin in 93 on the customer service / help desk, I would have many people who would call and ask if there was any way to not die in the simulator at the beginning of the game. They almost seemed sad when I told them, it was suppose to work that way and it was not something they could change.

  20. I actually went and watched the movie for the first time after watching this review a few weeks ago.

    Great video, Clint.

  21. I remember fondly having spent many hours in gameplay till the point that I had become almost one with the gameplay in nailing every enemy ship. This was a fun game to play and was quite advanced at the time as compared to many other games of its type on the market. Your gameplay conjures many a fond memory. Thank you for sharing. 🙂

  22. Favorite memory of this game was if you failed a mission protecting cargo you could just go shoot up the Tiger's Claw lol.

  23. That feeling when you realise you have already watched this episode a year ago, but LGR is so good you keep watching anyway.

  24. the gog edition also perfectly times it with dosbox which as you obviously noticed is tricky to do manually

  25. Star Citizen / Squadron 42 – what a joke.

    Even when Chris Roberts was at Origin Systems working on Wing Commander, he was known for long delays, and Privateer was only finished because his brother Erin Roberts took over the production.

    Sure, he's added some great features to SC and it looks shiny enough, but the one feature he keeps forgetting to add, like his previous games, is an actual release date. Unlike the previous endeavours, Chris Roberts is both lead designer and company CEO so no-one can hold him to account, with the result that there's almost no chance Star Citizen or Squadron 42 will ever be released as no-one will ever be able to get him to commit. Every year, we get new dates, and every year, they change.

    Then again, the longer he draws it out with continual promises of newer and shinier features, the more that people will continue to throw money at it, expecting that such features will one day be in a fully released product. After all, $200,000,000 and counting sounds like a pretty good scheme so far.

    Even as a movie producer, he's useless. The Wing Commander movie bombed, and since then, even actor Kevin Costner has sued him for breach of contract on a – wait for it – unreleased project.

    Why do people still think he'll release anything? His past track record doesn't exactly fill me with enthusiasm.

    PS: Yes, I did "pledge" to SC, several years ago and have even played several extremely buggy and poorly optimised builds, however, when I realised that (despite assurances from CIG) there was never going to be a concrete release date, I tried for a refund. After months of jumping through their hoops with no result, I simply gave up expecting ethical behaviour from CIG.

  26. This was an awesome game, extraordinarily designed compared to the technical opportunities of the time.

  27. Hey i still to this day argue that the wing commander movie IS a good movie especially if you watched it first before even knowning there is a game series

  28. That was not a "bowl cut". Sorry to be a pedant. Not that it sounds any better in hindsight, but that was "curtains". Along with a 0.5 undercut, it was my go-to style back then. (Don't laugh, many of you were doing it, too.)

  29. While this was a great game, I loved the Privateer version even better!! One of my favorite games ever!!

  30. My computer came with Wing Commander 2. I was terrible at it but I adored it and played the hell out of it, not that I got anywhere near completing it.

  31. I'm new to this channel and love it! Have you/he ever reviewed Star Trek 25th anniversary or Judgment Rites? This game reminded me of those games.

  32. Yikes! I almost cried LGR thanks for the nostalgia thank-you for taking me back in time to my childhood as a hardcore pc gamer from 1983-2019. I loved Wing Commander more than homework as a kid. I wish I could go back in time to this era.

  33. This game is what got me into gaming even more hardcore and motivated me to get my first game pad lol. Played them all including getting the voice packs. It kinda went downhill towards the end though.

  34. well that took me back! awesome game! played it through several times…one thing I remember was, that with a Roland card, the laser sound would come from a piano…quite hilarious!

  35. This is one of the first PC games I played on my new 486DX / 40MHz with 2 MB RAM, 110 MB of PC-AT hard drive. I remember trying to use the memory manager as QEMM to free extended RAM to get images and sounds. QEMM helped my DOS free more memory above the 640K limit so you could see the pilot's hand controlling the starfighter and the speech dialogue otherwise you wouldn't see this goodies … I love this game … don't forget to mention that this game had so much success at this time, that the second and third part, real actors appeared in games like Mark Hamill, Malcolm Mcdowell, John Ryes Davis, Tom Wilson, etc. A great game

  36. Played it on our 386 when I was 13… I got so hooked my parents had to carry me to bed every night… God, those clips and the music bring back lots of fond memories!😍
    Also Im German and as a kid only understood half of what was going on which just added to the aura of the game…

  37. I remember playing that game. One of my all-time favorite games, at least in that early era of PC gaming. Total break-through in gaming experience. I don't think it was beaten in fun-factor until DOOM. Loved playing Luke Skywalker!

  38. I had the SNES version. Funny when I fired all my missiles at an ace Kilrathi, and he would fly past a couple minutes later, with the missiles still chasing him..

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *